Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Redcrosse's avatar

I live on FIlipino shores and sometimes I look around me and think: "What if this place were run by Americans?" It's obvious, but it's hate speech these days, that it would quickly turn into a Hong Kong of the Sulu Sea. The answer you seek cannot be reduced to one simple insight, because humanity is a complicated tapestry. So while it's true that Japan is an explosion of wealth and creativity, as colonizers they were destructive barbarians, not builders, but sort of like ISIS with battle ships and samurai swords. Modern Chinese colonialism is an elaborate scam consisting of butt-wipe contracts and tofu-dreg projects that fall apart even while they're under construction. The only way to enrich the whole world so people stay where they were born, if that's a commendable goal, would be to actively encourage European re-colonization of parts of the world which lack competence to rule themselves. Your underlying assumption is that everybody deserves to be rich, safe, and modernized, when what they deserve is the sort of home they have created for themselves.

Warthog's avatar

Perhaps we should learn from and adapt for today's needs, the practices of the Victorian Brits.

Whatever anyone may think of The Socialist Islamic Dystopia of Formerly Great Britain, as imperialists first, and colonizers a distant second, they did a damned good job of civilizing savage regions of the world, before white guilt overwhelmed their inbuilt sense of self preservation.

Everywhere they went they not only imposed order by force and backed it by law, they built institutions, trained locals for military and civic duties and exploited natural resources that the local cultures could not have dreamed of exploiting. They created infrastructures that survive to this day. The cultures that built most successfully on that heritage are India, Kenya and Nigeria, all of whom retained their dominant cultural characteristics. The least successful ones look and govern like Zimbabwe. Mahatma Ghandi was a British lawyer before he was an anti colonialist.

Most of the Brits eschewed integration with the locals and coined the derogatory "gone native" for those who did. The majority assumed that they would return "home" when their tours of duty were over and by far the majority did so. They lived more privileged lives abroad than they might have in Britain and benefited from the right to return to Britain "on leave", which stimulated a steady and lucrative demand for to and fro passenger traffic by sea.

Given that imposing such arrangement these days tends to evoke quagmires and endless wars, perhaps the art of the deal might be adapted to a suitable carrot and stick collection of incentives?

15 more comments...

Ready for more?