Do you just see all black after you die? ChatGPT and Grok both told me it’s unlikely, because seeing black means you’re aware your senses are being deprived. Can you access your memories? No, Grok says once the brain starts rotting, then consciousness can’t really be experienced or generated. Can you even prove whether an afterlife exists?
For something that happens to nearly everyone, don’t you think it would be a great boon to humanity if we as humans were even 20% less unsure about what happens after you pass? You don’t have to be a Haight-Ashbury Buddhist to appreciate how much comfort and certainty it would bring to just about everyone on god’s increasingly hothouse Earth.
So what does this have to do with Race and IQ? More than you think. The question of whether the Black-White IQ gap, and the IQ gap between different racial and ethnic groups more widely, is something so radioactive that it turns even the most level-headed men and women into sputtering partisans. Like debating Pierre Trudeau, there are exceedingly few people in the world who are able to discuss racial IQ gaps calmly and dispassionately (let alone with panache). It not only brings out the worst in people but also exposes how pointless it can be to put one’s reason over other people’s passion.
Fears of a Classically Liberal Regime
Eric Turkheimer, considered by his peers one of the great geneticists of the last 30-odd years, once said that if IQ differences between races were more genetic than environmental, that finding would be equivalent to a nuclear bomb. While he recently said that he would’ve used more circumspect language, he still asserts that such a finding would have deeply negative consequences. He also believes, rightly or wrongly, that Race/IQ research is abhorrent. To him, studying the links between skin color and mental acuity is “valueless and harmful”; it only makes people miserable and adds nothing to human advancement.
This sentiment is often taken as a truism among most liberals, leftists, and educated people in the Western world.
Your average twenty-and-thirty-something, cooped up in his or her Flatbush shoebox, already believes that bigoted whites and their self-hating non-white friends have fallen prey to the far right through a mix of hopelessness and brainwashing. “If neoliberal shysters had not destroyed the welfare state, my MAGA parents would at least accept that America will never be and should never be White again,” he or she says as she savors a well-earned hot cocoa on a mid-November Friday night.
So if injustice and inequity were truly baked into all of us on the molecular level, then the far right could oppose equity itself on an empirical basis. They fear that an immaculately dressed Aryan statistician with perfect blue eyes and straight blonde hair will say on CNN: “This country has spent billions trying to help black and brown citizens reach their already limited potential. Every dollar spent on uplifting the weak is one that could be spent strengthening and refining capable men and women of all races.”
They fear that if the hereditarian hypothesis were even partly true, it would provide the perfect casus belli against the liberating possibility of a truly equal society. His or her children (they’re definitely coming, any day now) will be deprived of Dosas and Du Bois.
REEAaLUHTea
Here’s a problem with this folk belief: it isn’t even plausible. Your average voter, never mind your average white voter, does not think about race and intelligence any more than he or she thinks about the Doha round or the decline and downfall of the Irish Parliamentary Party. There are about as many openly white nationalist Americans as there are American vegetarians and vegans.
Based on my reading of the scant polling on this question, only about 13.5% of young white men do have white nationalist tendencies. Perhaps up to one third of white Americans have some latent white nationalist beliefs, but that’s nothing to work with given the ever-diversifying electorate. Even the most polite and intelligent white nationalists, such as Jared Taylor and Eric Orwoll, know the jig is up. Republicans are never going to tolerate any form of open and blatant white identity politics because it offends their undying belief in an ever-perfecting creedal nationhood.
If you talk to enough normal Republicans, especially in strongholds like Yavapai County, they believe the right message and the right candidate will finally make immigrants realize they are “natural conservatives”. No matter how much evidence to the contrary is staring them in the face, it’s the one thing that keeps Republicans going.
Would incontrovertible proof that Black Americans really do have an average IQ of 85 through no fault of anyone finally unleash a torrent of latent white supremacism? Will Title Two of the Civil Rights Act finally meet its deserved, gruesome end? Will future three-star Michelin restaurants and five-star hotels in Charleston finally put up a “BIPOC need not enter” sign? Will some entrepreneurial Nuyorican start publishing “The Non-White Vacationer’s Red Book, 2030-31”?
You could argue that such incontrovertible proof would encourage more redistribution, stronger anti-discrimination law, and reparations for underprivileged groups. Liberal modernity has always utilized social democracy to cure deep-seated ills. Would a perfect admixture study stop that? No; in fact, you can already imagine many a liberal leftist claiming that Black and Brown people, disadvantaged through no fault of their own, need to be made whole via taxes and transfers. Why should a Mexican Janitor or a Guyanese maid and her son miss out on something approximating a middle-class life because of his genes? If proof of the hereditarian hypothesis were incontrovertible, it wouldn’t take long for liberals and leftists to argue that White America had a moral duty to provide for its burgeoning non-white population because of innate gaps. I can already hear Amina from Swarthmore say, “Nobody chooses to have an IQ of 85, so why wouldn’t you support interest-free BIPOC scale-up loans.”
Moreover, if such latent hatred really did exist and could be aroused by firm confirmation that the average dark-skinned person is naturally less intelligent than ordinary pale-skinned and yellow-skinned people, we’d be seeing a second great migration to Minnesota, Addis Ababa, and the nicer parts of Soweto and Soshanguve long before some evil race scientist publishes his first historic preprints. And yet, Black Southerners aren’t going anywhere.
So why talk about it at all?
The Race and IQ debate, like all genuinely consequential and important questions, holds deep, probing power because it goes to the heart of human existence: Why are things the way they are? Why is Central Chile poorer than Central California, when they both share the same hospitable climate? We experience these gaps every single day when we walk through poor neighborhoods, try to teach undisciplined schoolchildren, see our friends and family suffer from Sickle Cell disease. Like the tantalizing possibility of life after death, we humans crave certainty and clarity to cope with unending stagnation and strife.
If you find yourself in a Puerto Rican neighborhood, a Chinese supermarket in Arcadia, or a Mexican San Franciscan’s college dorm room, you’ll hear them debate the same questions that we mentally unbalanced Far Right intellectuals debate, albeit in more normal and euphemistic language.
Why is the average White country far more livable than the average Non-White country? Why do black and brown grandmothers worship a White Jesus? Why do we live in a world still shaped by the actions of now-reviled colonizers like John Frobisher and Walter Raleigh?
Why do young Asian American students spend every waking hour trying to gain admission to prestigious Western institutions (be it a university, charity, or a fast food chain)? Is it really because Asians want to live lives that would make John Harvard proud? Do Asian Americans really care for Ray Kroc’s life story and how he turned a burger stand into a worldwide corporation? If Asian Americans only cared for prestige, why don’t more of us try to work at Rapidus, TSMC, or Ant Group?
Answering these controversial and dispiriting questions is just as important to Blacks, Asians, Latinos, and Middle Easterners as it is to Whites because they all relate to why we choose to live the way we do.
The best way to heal our broken, impoverished world is to discuss and debate uncomfortable topics so we can find whatever we can consider the truth. And once the truth sets us free, we can change what we can, or at least take comfort in knowing why things are the way they are. If the hereditarian hypothesis is true, humanity could eventually develop the tools to change it. And once that happens, I’ll be put out of business.



Surely the impracticalities of mass immigration and multiculturalism will kill off any magnanimity eventually? Only the tribal survive mass mixings of people. The colour-blind get wiped out first.
In Britain some recently imported groups are flourishing while the natives decline. They still play by the old universal playbook while newcomers ruthlessly vote their own into positions of authority then canvas for their own interests. That process ultimately establishes hard ethnocentrism as the only game in town, no matter how liberal people think they are.
Interesting take. I want the research to happen in earnest. I want the details. But between us, I don't really buy your argument. It would likely be a net negative for multicultural society.
Sake of argument, lets narrow the discussion to blacks. Black people in particular have unfathomably comical ways to justify their universal failure as a race. I strongly believe that's a good thing. I see no upside in reiterating that Wakanda isn't real, that we wasn't, in fact, kangz, we wasn't peanut butter, etc. They need these myths. Deeply. Do you know how common it is for black men to refer to each other as kings in ordinary life? That's not a meme. They do this. Why? A trivial cultural tic that I'm overextrapolating? I don't think so.
That the excuses for black failure are so goofy serves as evidence of how much black folk need them. Their collective self-image matters deeply to them; they aren't goofy neoliberal white women.
I'm certain that the mental health of the Western black man would take a meaningful blow if the data was indisputable. Their behavior would get even worse as their self-esteem crumbles. Whites simply can't afford to live with those consequences. As AI advances and UBI becomes inevitable, low IQ people will feel increasingly isolated as their perceived usefulness to society evaporates. Adding fuel to this fire is probably a bad idea.
As for the upsides, come on. We already know what time it is. Everybody does. Literally babies do. The exact details would be interesting, sure. But at a certain point, convergent experience ceases to be mere anecdote and starts to become evidence.