Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Spiff's avatar

Surely the impracticalities of mass immigration and multiculturalism will kill off any magnanimity eventually? Only the tribal survive mass mixings of people. The colour-blind get wiped out first.

In Britain some recently imported groups are flourishing while the natives decline. They still play by the old universal playbook while newcomers ruthlessly vote their own into positions of authority then canvas for their own interests. That process ultimately establishes hard ethnocentrism as the only game in town, no matter how liberal people think they are.

Ryan's avatar

Interesting take. I want the research to happen in earnest. I want the details. But between us, I don't really buy your argument. It would likely be a net negative for multicultural society.

Sake of argument, lets narrow the discussion to blacks. Black people in particular have unfathomably comical ways to justify their universal failure as a race. I strongly believe that's a good thing. I see no upside in reiterating that Wakanda isn't real, that we wasn't, in fact, kangz, we wasn't peanut butter, etc. They need these myths. Deeply. Do you know how common it is for black men to refer to each other as kings in ordinary life? That's not a meme. They do this. Why? A trivial cultural tic that I'm overextrapolating? I don't think so.

That the excuses for black failure are so goofy serves as evidence of how much black folk need them. Their collective self-image matters deeply to them; they aren't goofy neoliberal white women.

I'm certain that the mental health of the Western black man would take a meaningful blow if the data was indisputable. Their behavior would get even worse as their self-esteem crumbles. Whites simply can't afford to live with those consequences. As AI advances and UBI becomes inevitable, low IQ people will feel increasingly isolated as their perceived usefulness to society evaporates. Adding fuel to this fire is probably a bad idea.

As for the upsides, come on. We already know what time it is. Everybody does. Literally babies do. The exact details would be interesting, sure. But at a certain point, convergent experience ceases to be mere anecdote and starts to become evidence.

18 more comments...

Ready for more?